Wood Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles – Stop Wasting Money on the Wrong Roof

Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles is a choice many homeowners don’t fully understand until it’s too late and the wrong one can cost you time, money, and comfort. 

Shakes are bold and rustic, hand–split with a rough, natural finish. Shingles are smoother, more uniform, and easier to maintain. Each one has pros and cons depending on where you live, how long you want the roof to last, and how much you’re ready to spend not just upfront, but over time.

Here’s what you’ll learn in this guide:

• The real differences between wood shake roofs and shingles from appearance to how they’re made.
• Which option holds up better in your local weather, and how long each type can truly last.
• What each roof will cost (materials + labor), with updated pricing tables you can trust.
• Pro-level advice on maintenance, installation, and resale value so you don’t waste money down the line.

What’s the Difference Between Wood Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles?

Both wood shakes and shingles are made from cedar, redwood, or other rot-resistant woods. But they don’t look or perform the same.

Shingles are smooth and flat. They’re machine-sawn on both sides and cut into uniform rectangles. This gives your roof a neat, tidy pattern like rows of tiles.

Shakes, on the other hand, are hand-split on one side and sawed on the back. They’re thicker, rougher, and more textured. That makes your roof look more natural and rustic like something you’d see on a historic cottage or a mountain lodge.

Expert Insight: Roofers often say, “If you want clean lines, go shingles. If you want character, go shakes.”

But looks are just the start. Here’s a side-by-side Wood Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles breakdown:

You’re not just choosing a material. You’re choosing a look, a lifestyle, and a long-term budget.

Which Lasts Longer: Wood Shake Roof or Shingles?

You want a roof that holds up. That means resisting weather, bugs, and time itself. So, how do shakes and shingles hold up over the years?

Wood shingles, being thinner, tend to last about 20–30 years with good care. If you live in a dry climate and clean your roof regularly, you might squeeze out 35 years.

Wood shakes are thicker, so they offer more durability. They can last 30–40 years, sometimes up to 50 years in ideal conditions. But they also need more careful installation to breathe and dry out properly.

Let’s break it down:

Pro Tip: Go for pressure-treated shakes if you live in a damp or coastal area. They’re treated to resist rot, fire, and insects.

Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles: How Much Does Each Roof Cost?

Let’s talk dollars. Cost is one of the biggest dealbreakers or dealmakers when choosing between a wood shake roof and shingles.

Material Cost per Square Foot (2024–2025 Estimate):

Expert Insight: Prices vary based on location, wood type (cedar is the most common), and roof complexity. Labor also matters. Installing shakes takes more time and skill.

In cities like NYC, Boston, or San Francisco, shake roofing may even cost 25–35% more due to permit requirements, insurance premiums, and regional supply.

Shingles Roof vs Wood Shake: Which Roof Type Handles Weather Better?

Weather can destroy a roof before its time. So, how do these two options perform under pressure?

Wood shingles do fine in mild climates but can struggle with high humidity. They lay flat, so they dry faster. But they’re thinner and can crack under heavy snow or hail.

Wood shakes, being thicker, offer better impact resistance and insulation. But they need more breathing room and underlayment to resist mold, especially in humid zones.

Climate Breakdown:

In places like Colorado or Maine, shakes often outperform shingles thanks to extra thickness. But in Florida or the Gulf Coast, treated shingles may be easier to maintain.

Wood Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles: Which Requires More Maintenance?

Let’s be real: all wood roofs need love. But some need more than others.

Wood shingles are easier to maintain. They’re thinner and less prone to warping, and their even layout makes inspection and cleaning faster.

Wood shakes need more attention. Because they’re thicker and uneven, they can trap more debris and moisture. That means more cleaning and checking for moss, rot, or lifting edges.

Maintenance Task Checklist:

Pro Tip: Apply a roof treatment every 3–5 years to repel water, block UV damage, and kill moss spores.

What About Insurance and Building Code Issues?

This is where many homeowners get tripped up. Some cities and insurance companies aren’t friendly to wood roofs, especially in wildfire zones.

Insurance Flags:

• Wood shakes are often considered a fire risk unless treated.
• Some policies charge more for homes with untreated wood roofing.
• You may need Class A fire-rated shakes to meet code in fire-prone regions.

Building Codes:

• In California, Colorado, and parts of Texas, codes limit wood roof installation without fireproof treatment.
• Always check your local code before signing a contract.

Expert Insight: Many fire-rated shakes today are pressure-treated with fire retardants. Ask your roofer if the product meets ASTM E108 Class A standards.

Which Roof Looks Better: Wood Shake Roof or Shingles?

Let’s not forget how much looks matter, especially if you’re planning to sell soon. Curb appeal can add 7–10% to your home’s value, according to Zillow.

Wood shakes offer rich texture, depth, and a custom feel. They work best on Craftsman, Cape Cod, or rustic–style homes.

Wood shingles give a cleaner, uniform look. They’re great for Colonial, Farmhouse, or mid–century homes.

Style Breakdown:

Should You Choose Wood at All or Go with Lookalikes?

If you love the natural look but not the upkeep, you’re not alone. Many homeowners now choose synthetic shakes or composite shingles that mimic wood, without the drawbacks.

Wood vs Composite:

Brands like DaVinci Roofscapes and Brava offer premium composite shakes that look almost identical to hand-split wood.

Conclusion: So, Which One’s Right for You?

Here’s the deal. If you want a roof that looks high-end, lasts decades, and don’t mind some extra maintenance, wood shakes deliver a bold, rustic charm you can’t fake. If you’re more budget-conscious or want something easier to manage, wood shingles are a smart, clean-looking option.

Still can’t decide? Let the experts help.

If you’re in Brooklyn or nearby, consider reaching out to S & R General Construction NYC. They specialize in both wood and composite roofing. Their team can inspect your roof, review local codes, and give you a real quote, not a sales pitch.

Ready to take the next step? Don’t wait until that first leak or warped board forces your hand. Compare options now. Ask questions. Get samples. And choose a roof that fits your life, not just your house.

Frequently Asked Questions: Wood Shake Roof vs Shingles